12 Oct 2008: Dutch Oven Cooking Experiment
Equipment
Dutch Oven Stand
Verdict: Great tool. I would like a couple more.
Where It Worked Well:
- Keeping coals off of wood deck.
- Place to put coals for bottom heat. Stable.
What I Would Tweak In Its Design:
- I would prefer slightly larger, perhaps 2-3″ per side.
Wire Trivet
Verdict: Great tool. I would like a couple more.
Where It Worked Well:
- Raising pot off coals.
- Protecting surfaces from hot pot.
- Holder for inverted lid.
Where It Worked Poorly:
- Too tall to work as in-pan trivet.
Wisk Broom
Verdict: Necessary, but fair tool.
Where It Worked Well:
- Removing bulk of ash.
Where It Worked Poorly:
- Removing last layer of fine ash. Blowing with breath removed enough. Try compressed air.
Other Equipment Notes
- I prefer the leg-bearing and flanged D.O.s to the unflanged pot. Buy an additional 10″ D.O.
- I would like a 10″ deep skillet with skillet lid, like the 12″ we have. I’m suspicious about ash in the food.
- I would like an additional 12″ D.O. so I can make a full batch of potato rolls.
- I wonder whether I could get frying temperatures with a smaller chimney.
- Compressed air can seemed to remove all the dust and ash.
Food
Corn Bread
Verdict: Very good. Slightly burned on bottom.
What Worked: Adding a couple of bricks to raise temperature.
Tweaks to Try:
- A couple fewer bricks, or remove bottom heat earlier.
- Take out of D.O. and let cool on rack. If you let it cool in the D.O. condensation makes the bottom soggy after a while.
- M. made corn bread in her 10″ D.O. She did everything except place the initial set of coals on the D.O.
- I counted out 10±3 bricks, added 2 bricks to raise temperature from 325° to 350°, and added 2 more bricks because it was slightly cold.
- We used ⅔ timing.
Peach Cobbler
Verdict: Failure. Burned on top. The rest was overcooked.
What Worked: Draining peaches.
Tweaks to Try: Watch the clock.
- Used the 10″ pot without the flange or legs.
- Raised the pot on the trivet so it was not sitting directly on the coals
- Lost track of time. Looks like the peach goo on the bottom protected it from burning.
- Cobbler flipped upside down just fine. Some peach goo stuck to the bottom.
Potato Rolls
Verdict: Slightly overcooked, visually perfect.
What Worked: Letting rolls raise in warm oven.
Tweaks to Try: If they’re just starting to turn golden, they should be done.
- Prepared dough, placed one batch in the 12″ D.O. and the other in the 12″ deep frying pan with the frying pan lid for the final raising.
- My intention was to cook the D.O. outside, and the pan in the oven so we’d have at least one good set of rolls if I ruined the D.O. batch.
- I put the D.O. in the warm oven. The pan I put in my office.
- The D.O. rolls rose perfectly. The office was apparently not warm enough for the yeast, and didn’t rise properly.
- Dinner was pending, so I threw the D.O. in the oven and let L. care for it.
- Repeated last time’s mistake. After 10 minutes the rolls were done, but not not all of them golden. Put them in for another 5 minutes. They were golden, but a bit overcooked.
- The rolls were stuck to the bottom of the pan and a little brittle on the bottom because they were slightly overcooked. Could not flip them out.
- Put the pan in the warm oven to let the other rolls finish rising. Will cook later tonight.
Spaghetti Sauce
Verdict: Perfect given limited ingredients.
What Worked:
- Putting pan directly on coals.
- I went easy on the home-grown basil. It’s much more potent than the store-bought basil.
Tweaks to Try: Use pan with lid.
- Cooked in 10″ cast iron frying pan.
- Chimney is only good for low heat. It is no good for frying temperatures.
- Cooked directly on coals for higher temperatures.
- Do not cook next to downwind D.O. I’m suspicious that some ash may have been blown into sauce, but nobody could tell whether it was true.

Leave a Reply